Best Sifting Litter Boxes 2019 – We Sifted out the Best Ones for You

You love and adore your feline companion. But let’s be honest, cleaning out their waste is certainly not one of your most favorite past-times. So, what to do to make this unpleasant chore a bit easier?

Sifting cat litter boxes might be the solution to this problem. They make the chore of cleaning your kitty’s toilet much easier and quicker, help to reduce bad odor and even save litter.

To help you find the perfect sifting litter box for you and your purring goddess or god, we spent more than a dozen hours to research and sift out the very best ones you can get. We’ve taken into consideration the needs of different cat parents and their kitties and found the best ones in various categories.

Keep on reading to find out which one is the right one for you and your cat.

These Are the 7 Best Sifting Litter Boxes 2019

1. Van Ness Sifting Enclosed Cat Litter Pan (Best Overall)

This is our overall star when it comes to sifting litter boxes. It comes in two different sizes, large and extra giant. Because of that, this litter pan is perfect for your large cat or if you’re the proud parent of multiple cats.

The Van Ness Sifting Enclosed Cat Litter Pan comes with an easy-to-use 3-pan sifting system. It consists of two regular pans, a sifting pan, and a hood.

This box has all the advantages you get from a hooded cat litter box. It offers your cats privacy while following nature’s call and keeps their business from view. The swinging door makes it easy for your cat to enter and exit their toilet and also helps to keep unpleasant odors inside. Due to the enclosed design, even felines that tend to splash or dig their litter enthusiastically can’t make a mess outside of their box.

An Important Tip for Effective Use

The manufacturer tells you to stack it the following way: regular pan + second regular pan + sifting pan on top.

But many users have found for themselves that if they do it this way, then dirt and wet litter get stuck on the sifting pan. That’s difficult to clean and makes sifting inefficient. Instead, users recommend to put the sifting pan in between the two regular pans and stacking it this way: regular pan + sifting pan + second regular pan on top. This way, you only use the sifting pan for sifting and it stays clean.

Color (Large): Golden Brown

Color (Extra Giant): Blue

Dimensions (Large): 19.5 x 15.2 x 17.5 in (50 x 39 x 44 cm)

Dimensions (Extra Giant): 21.5 x 17.5 x 18 in (55 x 45 x 46 cm)

Preciously Likes

  • enclosed design provides privacy and safety
  • suitable for large cats or multiple cats
  • odor control through enclosed design, swinging door and air filter
  • durable and odor and stain-resistant high-polish finish
  • easy to clean and maintain
  • made from FDA-approved materials
  • made in the USA
  • available in 2 sizes

Preciously Dislikes

  • air filter has to be changed regularly
  • wet litter and dirt can get stuck in the sifting pan if stacked incorrectly

2. Pet Mate Arm & Hammer Large Sifting Litter Pan (Best Budget)

This is the most affordable sifting cat litter box on our list. It’s simple and straightforward but still a great sifting litter box that gets the job done and it’s definitely great value for money.

The Pet Mate Arm & Hammer Large Sifting Litter Pan features an easy-to-use and effective system that consists of three stackable pans, two regular ones, and a sifting pan. The sifting pan has holes in it that allow clean litter to fall through without scooping or shaking. This makes separating your kitty’s waste from clean litter easy and efficient.

This litter box has also the added benefit of offering you antimicrobial protection. This reduces unpleasant stains and odor and makes it easy to clean.

Dimensions: 18.9 x 15.2 x 7.9 in (48 x 36.6 x 20 cm)

Preciously Likes

  • provides antimicrobial protection against stains and odor
  • made from durable, reinforced materials
  • easy to use and effective
  • very affordable
  • great value for a low price

Preciously Dislikes

  • rather small for large or multiple cats
  • sides might be too low for some cats that tend to kick litter around

3. SpeedySift Cat Litter Box (Best Easy and Quick Sifting)

A sifting cat litter box can’t possibly be more convenient and hassle-free. This innovative litter system offers you the perfect solution if you want to sift in the easiest and quickest way possible.

The set includes a litter box and 56 liners that act as sieves. In order to sift the litter box’s contents, just lift up the liner and let it do its job of separating the clean litter from the garbage. You then just add a new liner to the litter pan and that’s it!

You don’t have to dump the litter into another container or shake the litter in order to sift it. This means very little dust is created during the sifting process. Also, because you can just change and throw away the sifting liners together with the cat waste, you have to deal with much less cleaning.

Something you should watch out for with the SpeedySift cat litter box is that you have to use non-lightweight clumping clay litter

Another thing we want to mention is that even though the litter box liners are very durable and claw-resistant, this litter box is probably not for you if your cat is a very active digger with sharp and untrimmed claws.

Dimensions: 20.9 x 17.9 x 4.9 in (53.1 x 45.5 x 12.4 cm)

Preciously Likes

  • easy, quick and clean sifting process
  • very little dust during sifting
  • little cleaning required
  • no dirty litter pan or sifter with stuck dirt and litter
  • biodegradable liners are also available
  • litter box has high sides, is durable and lightweight
  • suitable for kittens or senior cats (entrance can be trimmed and made lower)

Preciously Dislikes

  • liners have to be bought on a regular basis
  • produces plastic waste
  • not suitable for very active feline diggers with sharp and untrimmed claws

4. Omega Paw Roll ‘n Clean (Best Self-Cleaning)

This is the best self-cleaning cat litter box that doesn’t even require any electricity or expensive special litter! The cleaning process is purely mechanical. You just roll the litter box over and roll it back. That’s it! The sieve that’s contained inside the litter box separates your cat’s waste from clean litter. All you have to do then is take out the small drawer that contains the nasty bits and dump it.

Because of the easy cleaning process of the Roll’n Clean, you don’t have to take out any cat litter and then sift it manually. That also means you don’t have to deal with dust clouds.

This cat litter box comes in two sizes, regular and large. The regular size is suitable for a small cat. If you have a medium-sized or large cat or multiple cats, we’d recommend the large box.

The Roll’n Clean has been improved and is now made with stronger and more durable materials and improved locking clips that prevent litter from spilling out when rolling it.

Dimensions (Regular): 17 x 20 x 16.5 in (43 x 51 x 42 cm)

Dimensions (Large): 20 x 23 x 19 in (51 x 58.4 x 48 cm)

Preciously Likes

  • cleaning process couldn’t be easier and simpler
  • hooded design gives your cat privacy and safety
  • no manual sifting
  • little dust during the cleaning process
  • odor control through hooded design
  • no electricity, filters or liners required
  • available in 2 sizes

Preciously Dislikes

  • more expensive than other sifting cat litter boxes
  • obviously, you still need to do a manual deep cleaning on a regular basis

5. Van Ness Sifting Cat Pan/Litter Box with Frame (Best High-Sided)

This uncovered sifting cat litter box has a higher frame that helps to reduce or even prevent litter from being spilled by your feline digger. It consists of two regular pans, a sifting pan, and a frame. It has a clean design, is nice-looking and proof that even litter boxes don’t have to be ugly.

An Important Tip for Effective Use

Just as with the Sifting Enclosed Cat Litter Pan by Van Ness, the manufacturer tells you to stack it the following way: regular pan + second regular pan + sifting pan on top.

But many users have found for themselves that if they do it this way, then dirt and wet litter get stuck on the sifting pan. That’s difficult to clean and makes sifting inefficient. Instead, users recommend to put the sifting pan in between the two regular pans and stacking it this way: regular pan + sifting pan + second regular pan on top. This way, you only use the sifting pan for sifting and it stays clean.

Dimensions: 19 x 15.1 x 8 in (48 x 38.4 x 20.3 cm)

Preciously Likes

  • higher frame reduces spillage of litter
  • high-polish, stain-resistant material
  • very affordable
  • good-looking design
  • made in the USA
  • FDA approved materials

Preciously Dislikes

  • rather small for large cats or multiple cats
  • sifting pan gets clogged with dirt and wet litter if stacked incorrectly

6. Petmate Sifting Corner Litter Pan for Cats (Best Corner)

If you want a sifting cat litter box that takes away as little space as possible then this is the perfect one for you. This great litter box fits snugly into a corner while offering your purring goddess or god plenty of space to answer nature’s call.

It comes with three pans of which one is a sifting pan that sits between the other two pans. It has very high sides that should withstand the antics of happy diggers and keep litter where it belongs. At the same time, this litter box has a lower entrance that’s suitable for young kittens or senior cats.

Dimensions: 26 x 19 x 11.7 in (66 x 48.2 x 29.8 cm)

Preciously Likes

  • fits into a corner and needs little space
  • high sides help to prevent litter spillage
  • low-profile entrance provides easy access even to senior cats or kittens
  • suitable for large cats or multiple cats
  • made of eco-friendly, durable materials
  • made in the USA

Preciously Dislikes

  • sifting area could be a bit larger
  • more expensive than other uncovered sifting litter boxes

7. So Phresh Sifting Cat Litter Box (Best Uncovered for Large/Multi Cats)

This is a straightforward sifting cat litter box with a higher frame that helps to prevent your kitty from tossing litter out of its box. It has a simple 3-pan design that’s easy to use. It includes two regular and a sifting pan as well as a frame.

It comes in two sizes, standard and x-large. The regular size should work for most single cats and the x-large one is perfect for large/very large cats and multi-cat households. So, if you want an uncovered sifting cat litter box and have a majestic tomcat or multiple kitties, then you should go for this one.

Dimensions (Standard): 19.8 x 15.1 x 9.5 in (50.3 x 38.4 x 24 cm)

Dimensions (X-Large): 22.5 x 17.25 x 10.5 in (57.2 x 43.8 x 26.7 cm)

Preciously Likes

  • a higher frame helps to prevent litter spillage
  • larger than comparable uncovered sifting cat litter boxes
  • suitable for large cats or multiple cats
  • available in 2 sizes
  • made in the USA

Preciously Dislikes

  • handles are rather small
  • might work best with litter box liners

What You’ve Always Wanted to Know About Sifting Litter Boxes

What Is a Sifting Litter Box?

A sifting litter box is a type of cat toilet that removes your kitty’s waste by sifting it out with a sifting pan. It usually consists of one or two regular pans plus a sifting pan. Depending on the model, it can also have a frame or hood.

With this kind of litter box, you don’t have to scoop out the nasty bits by hand – the sifter does that for you. It separates waste from clean litter easily and quickly. Clumps of cat waste are filtered out and clean litter passes through the filter and is ready for reuse. That means you can also save money because you have to buy less litter.

One caveat of using a sifting litter box is that the sifting process produces dust. Therefore, especially loyal cat servants and their feline masters who have respiratory issues should be cautious.

But the use of dust-free litter helps to reduce dust. And there are also litter boxes that are designed to cut down on dust during the sifting process.

How Do You Use a Sifting Cat Litter Box?

You have to stack the pans in the following way to ensure the most efficient use: regular pan + sifting pan + regular pan.

Put the litter into the top regular pan. When it’s time to clean out your feline best friend’s waste, you take the top regular pan and pour its contents into the sifting pan. While passing the litter through the sifter, the garbage gets filtered out and the clean litter falls through into the second regular pan and can be reused.

You then just restack the pans so that the pan containing the cleaned litter goes on top. That’s it.

While sifting, you might need to shake the sifting pan a bit to ensure that all the litter moves through the sifting pan.

Because of this, we’d recommend you to only pick a model with three pans, two regular ones plus a sifting pan. The issue with 2-pan (a regular pan and a sifting one) sifting litter boxes is that you don’t have a second regular pan for the clean litter that passes through. That means you always need an extra container for the sifting process.

What Kind of Litter Can Be Used with a Sifting Cat Litter Box?

Self-clumping litter works best for a sifting litter box. With other types of litter, liquid waste might fall through the sifter and not get filtered out. It’s also important to use litter that’s fine enough to pass through the sifting pan easily. And because the process of sifting litter creates dust, we recommend the use of dust-free litter.

How Do You Choose the Right One for You and Your Cat?

You should take the following into consideration when buying one.

Hooded or Open

It depends on your cat’s preference whether to get an enclosed or uncovered litter box. Some kitties just need more privacy and a feeling of security when doing their business. A hood provides this.

A hooded litter box also keeps litter and dirt inside an enclosed space which is especially important for very enthusiastic feline diggers. At the same time, a hood controls odor better and shields your cat’s toilet from view. This way, you don’t have to see and smell the natural end-products of your kitty’s digestion process.

Size and Shape

A litter box’s size is especially important if you have a large cat or multiple feline companions. You should always check the dimensions of a litter box before buying it. Some litter boxes come in different sizes to accommodate large or multiple cats.

Other things to consider are whether you need a box with high sides that help to keep litter inside. For kittens and senior cats, you should also check whether the entrance is low enough.

Cleaning and Maintenance

Even though a sifting cat litter box makes the daily chore of cleaning your feline companion’s toilet easier and quicker, you still have to do some work. You still have to do deep cleaning and maintenance on a regular basis.

That’s why you should consider the ease of use of a litter box as well as how much work is involved in its maintenance. Also, in some cases, recurring costs might occur, for example for litter box liner, air filters and such.

Odor Control

The avoidance of unpleasant odors is another important factor when it comes to choosing the right litter box. No matter how elegant and graceful your feline is, it ain’t roses that come out of their backside. Naturally, you don’t want to smell your kitty’s waste all over your home.

Especially with an uncovered litter box, you have to keep it clean and not just remove the waste daily or every few days but also clean the box itself from stains on a regular basis. An enclosed design with a hood helps to cut down on odor but that doesn’t mean you have to clean it less often.

Preciously Summary – Who Should Get Which?

We know your time is valuable. That’s why we’ve included a summary of our recommendations for the best sifting litter boxes to help you with your decision. Read on for a quick overview of which one is for you depending on your and your kitty’s needs.

1. Van Ness Sifting Enclosed Cat Litter Pan (Best Overall)

This is the right sifting litter box for you if your meowy creature prefers a hooded design that gives them privacy and safety. It also keeps unpleasant odor and kicked-up litter inside. You have the choice between two sizes which makes it perfect for large cats for multiple cats.

2. Pet Mate Arm & Hammer Large Sifting Litter Pan (Best Budget)

This is the most affordable one of our recommendations and it’s perfect if you’re on a budget and still want a great uncovered sifting litter box. It definitely gives you great value for money. It’s easy to use, very effective and has antimicrobial protection against stains and odor.

3. SpeedySift Cat Litter Box (Best Easy and Quick Sifting)

If you want all the advantages of a sifting litter box and cut down on the disadvantages, this innovative litter box system gives you what you want. With this system, you use litter box liners for the sifting process. This means much easier use, less dust, and less cleaning. But with this litter box, you do have to buy liners on a regular basis.

4. Omega Paw Roll’ n Clean (Best Self-Cleaning)

This hooded litter box is for you and your kitty is you want an automatic cleaning process without having to use any electricity. You filter out your furry sweetheart’s waste by simply rolling the box and rolling it back. That’s it! The hooded design is also good for giving your cat privacy and keeping bad odor inside. It also comes in two sizes.

5. Van Ness Sifting Cat Pan/Litter Box with Frame (Best High-Sided)

If your furry baby has a habit of kicking up litter in their box and you’re looking for an uncovered litter box that helps to keep litter inside, you’ve found it. This litter box has a nice design with a higher frame that should prevent your happy digger from spreading litter on the floor.

6. Petmate Sifting Corner Litter Pan for Cats (Best Corner)

Only got a tiny corner space for a litter box? No problem! This is a sifting litter box that fist snugly into a corner and takes away little space. It also has high sides for better protection and a low-profile entrance that’s perfect for senior cats for kittens. At the same time, it offers enough space even for larger felines.

7. So Phresh Sifting Cat Litter Box (Best Uncovered for Large/Multi Cats)

If your feline has a respectable size or if you’re the proud servant to multiple cats and you want an uncovered litter box, you should go for this one. This is an open litter box with a higher frame to prevent litter spillage. It comes in two sizes.

Leave a Comment